The evolution of MarR family transcription factors as counter-silencers in regulatory networks
Introduction
In his book Evolution by Gene Duplication [1], Susumu Ohno argued that gene duplication is a driving force in evolution, suggesting that ‘natural selection (has) merely modified, while redundancy created.’ He posited that gene duplications and the redundancy they produce provide the evolutionary space necessary for functional diversification and innovation. Duplication allows the exploration of otherwise ‘forbidden’ mutations, generating novel functions unique from those of the ancestral gene, ultimately resulting in greater organismal complexity. In the absence of gene duplication, mutations are limited to those that do not disrupt essential gene function, constraining potential evolutionary trajectories. Although more recent evolutionary studies suggest that horizontal gene transfer has a greater impact on bacterial evolution than classical intragenomic duplication [2, 3, 4], Ohno’s ideas are relevant here as well, as the expansion of a gene family by extensive lateral transfer also provides valuable evolutionary space. These processes are exemplified by the evolution of gene regulatory networks. Transcription is typically regulated by transcription factors (TFs), which bind near gene promoters to modulate their transcription by RNA polymerase (RNAP). Although one genome may encode hundreds of unique TFs, these belong to as few as 10 unique TF families [5,6]. The TFs contained within each family are the products of gene duplication, and the maintenance of these duplicates implies a fitness advantage. This can occur through neofunctionalization, wherein a duplicate acquires a novel function not present in the original gene, or subfunctionalization, wherein the function of an original gene is divided between two or more copies via mutational divergence [7]. TF gene duplication allows both in cis variation, resulting from changes in the promoter driving expression of a TF, which affects the binding and activity of upstream TFs and RNAP, or in trans variation, resulting from changes in the coding sequence of the TF, which alters interactions with cognate targets or other interaction partners. The net result of these duplication events and the resulting variation are increasingly complex regulatory networks that are able to respond to a variety of environmental and physiological stimuli.
The MarR (Multiple antibiotic resistance Regulator) family of TFs (MFTFs) exemplifies these processes. MFTFs are ancient, predating the divergence of Archaea and Bacteria [8] and presently comprising one of the most common TF families in bacteria. Although the average bacterial genome encodes seven unique MFTFs [9], the number can vary widely: Bacillus subtilis and Streptomyces coelicolor encode at least 20 each (depending on the strain), whereas Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium encodes seven, and the related enteric species Yersinia pseudotuberculosis encodes only three. Even endosymbiotic species, which have undergone substantial genome loss, encode multiple MFTFs, including Sodalis glossinidius, which encodes five [10••,11•]. Despite their significant presence in bacteria, MFTFs exhibit limited sequence conservation between lineages, typically with less than 30% identity. This variability may reflect the inherent versatility of the MFTF backbone that allows them to interact with a variety of targets and respond to a variety of physiological and environmental signals. The ubiquity of MFTFs, particularly in the reduced genomes of endosymbiotic species, suggests that they serve an underappreciated role as central regulators of bacterial gene expression.
MFTFs were first recognized when Escherichia coli mutants exhibiting heightened resistance to multiple antibiotics were observed to encode mutations in MarR, the prototypical MFTF [12]. Since that discovery, MFTFs have been found to play a role in a number of important biological processes, including antibiotic resistance, virulence [13], oxidative stress [14], central metabolism [9,15], and the catabolism of a variety of aromatic compounds [9]. Although MFTFs were originally regarded as classical repressors of transcription, often of very small regulons, more recent studies have demonstrated that some members of the family can also function as global regulators, both positively and negatively modulating gene expression [11•,16,17]. This scenario is perhaps best exemplified by the SlyA MFTF lineage in Enterobacteriaceae, which has evolved to function as transcriptional counter-silencers [10••,16,18•,19]. SlyA proteins alleviate xenogeneic silencing of horizontally -acquired genes by proteins such as H-NS [20,21], thereby playing a vital role in the regulatory integration of horizontally -acquired genes. This allows a bacterial cell to realize a potential fitness benefit from horizontally -acquired genes, which might be detrimental if expressed in an unregulated fashion. Notably, SlyA is strongly conserved, as it is present in most species in the Enterobacteriaceae, including endosymbionts such as S. glossinidius and Wigglesworthia glossinidia, in which it is under strong selective constraints [22•]. The SlyA lineage is not unique in controlling large numbers of genes. ScoC, which belongs to a distinct MFTF lineage, positively and negatively regulates more than 560 genes in B. subtilis, which are involved in sporulation, transport, motility, and metabolism [23], although the mechanistic basis for its pleiotropic function is unknown. The existence of MFTFs functioning as both small regulon repressors and global counter-silencers provides a clear example of functional innovation and diversification as a consequence of gene duplication.
Section snippets
The MFTF DNA binding motif is highly variable
Regardless of their specific function, MFTFs are generally defined by four common features: (1) a single globular domain, containing both (2) a winged-helix-turn-helix (wHTH) DNA-binding motif [24,25] and (3) a ligand-binding site that allows allosteric inhibition by environmental or physiological signals [26], and (4) genetic linkage to a multi-drug efflux pump. The chimeric wHTH (Figure 1) domain consists of a classical prokaryotic helix-turn-helix motif, in which the recognition helix (α4)
MFTFs are allosterically inhibited by multiple stimuli
The mechanism of allosteric inhibition, which sensitizes MFTFs to physiological and environmental stimuli, is a point of conjecture for MarR. Early studies observed that multi-drug resistance could be induced by the addition of salicylate to E. coli cultures [43], which was later shown to result from the inhibition of MarR-mediated DNA binding and repression [44]. Because MFTFs are comprised of a singular globular domain, ligand binding can easily impact interaction with DNA. The binding of
Genetic linkage to transporters suggests a physiological function for MFTFs
The third common feature of MFTFs, genetic linkage to efflux pumps or transporters, may reflect the primordial function of this protein family. In S. Typhimurium, four out of seven MFTF genes are genetically linked to multi-drug efflux pump or transporter-encoding genes (Figure 3), including the pleiotropic counter-silencer SlyA, although this linkage has been lost in most other enteric species, including endosymbiotic species. This suggests that, although SlyA may be under selective
Variation in cis has contributed to pleiotropic function
As mentioned above, cis-level variation, which alters the expression of individual MFTFs, can also contribute to regulatory evolution and functional adaptation. This was recently demonstrated in an analysis of SlyA alleles from S. Typhimurium and E. coli. Although allelic exchange demonstrated that both alleles are capable of functioning as counter-silencers in S. Typhimurium [10••], SlyA does not play a significant role in the E. coli regulatory network [46•,47,48], apparently because of low
Conclusions
Gene duplication appears to have facilitated the asymmetrical adaptation of MFTF lineages (Figure 2). Although recent studies have highlighted the prominence of horizontal gene transfer in bacterial evolution [2,4], these studies are typically limited to the last 100 million years. We do not dispute that horizontal gene transfer has played a role in MFTF expansion, as some lineages are suggested to have been acquired via horizontal gene transfer, such as HucR of Deinococcus radiodurans [64].
Conflict of interest statement
Nothing declared.
References and recommended reading
Papers of particular interest, published within the period of review, have been highlighted as:
• of special interest
•• of outstanding interest
Acknowledgement
The National Institutes of Health provided support to F.C.F. (Grant numbers: AI39557, AI44486, AI118962, and AI112640).
References (76)
- et al.
Lineage-specific expansion of DNA-binding transcription factor families
Trends Genet
(2010) Regulation of metabolic pathways by MarR family transcription factors
Comput Struct Biotechnol J
(2017)- et al.
Chance and necessity in the genome evolution of endosymbiotic bacteria of insects
ISME J
(2017) - et al.
Control of virulence gene transcription by indirect readout in Vibrio cholerae and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium
Environ Microbiol
(2017) - et al.
SAV4189, a MarR-family regulator in Streptomyces avermitilis, activates avermectin biosynthesis
Front Microbiol
(2018) - et al.
DNA recognition by the Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium transcription factor SlyA
Int Microbiol
(2008) - et al.
The multiple antibiotic resistance operon of enteric bacteria controls DNA repair and outer membrane integrity
Nat Commun
(2017) - et al.
Structural analysis of the antibiotic-recognition mechanism of MarR proteins
Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr
(2013) - et al.
Antibiotic susceptibility profiles of Escherichia coli strains lacking multidrug efflux pump genes
Antimicrob Agents Chemother
(2001) - et al.
NGL viewer: web-based molecular graphics for large complexes
Bioinformatics
(2018)
Molecular cloning and characterization of the fusaric acid-resistance gene from Pseudomonas cepacia
Agric Biol Chem
RND transporters in the living world
Res Microbiol
Evolution by Gene Duplication
Horizontal transfer, not duplication, drives the expansion of protein families in prokaryotes
PLoS Genet
Modular networks and cumulative impact of lateral transfer in prokaryote genome evolution
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
Adaptive evolution of bacterial metabolic networks by horizontal gene transfer
Nat Genet
Genomic repertoires of DNA-binding transcription factors across the tree of life
Nucleic Acids Res
Toward a general model for the evolutionary dynamics of gene duplicates
Genome Biol Evol
Common history at the origin of the position-function correlation in transcriptional regulators in archaea and bacteria
J Mol Evol
The evolution of SlyA/RovA transcription factors from repressors to countersilencers in Enterobacteriaceae
MBio
The regulation of antimicrobial peptide resistance in the transition to insect symbiosis
Mol Microbiol
A multidrug resistance regulatory chromosomal locus is widespread among enteric bacteria
J Infect Dis
H-NS represses inv transcription in Yersinia enterocolitica through competition with RovA and interaction with YmoA
J Bacteriol
The OhrR repressor senses organic hydroperoxides by reversible formation of a cysteine-sulfenic acid derivative
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
The regulatory role of Streptomyces coelicolor TamR in central metabolism
Biochem J
Co-regulation of Salmonella enterica genes required for virulence and resistance to antimicrobial peptides by SlyA and PhoP/PhoQ
Mol Microbiol
RovA, a global regulator of Yersinia pestis, specifically required for bubonic plague
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
Evolutionary expansion of a regulatory network by counter-silencing
Nat Commun
Integrated circuits: how transcriptional silencing and counter-silencing facilitate bacterial evolution
Curr Opin Microbiol
Selective silencing of foreign DNA with low GC content by the H-NS protein in Salmonella
Science
H-NS mediates the silencing of laterally acquired genes in bacteria
PLoS Pathog
Correlation between Bacillus subtilis scoC phenotype and gene expression determined using microarrays for transcriptome analysis
J Bacteriol
The crystal structure of MarR, a regulator of multiple antibiotic resistance, at 2.3 A resolution
Nat Struct Biol
Structure of an OhrR-ohrA operator complex reveals the DNA binding mechanism of the MarR family
Mol Cell
Salicylate induction of antibiotic resistance in Escherichia coli: activation of the mar operon and a mar-independent pathway
J Bacteriol
Structural mechanism of transcription regulation of the Staphylococcus aureus multidrug efflux operon mepRA by the MarR family repressor MepR
Nucleic Acids Res
Structural characterization of the DNA-binding mechanism underlying the copper(II)-sensing MarR transcriptional regulator
J Biol Inorg Chem
The role of DNA shape in protein-DNA recognition
Nature
Cited by (16)
Small-angle x-ray and neutron scattering of MexR and its complex with DNA supports a conformational selection binding model
2023, Biophysical JournalCitation Excerpt :To our knowledge, this is the first time SANS has been used to study a MarR-type protein-DNA complex in solution, and this approach could well extend our understanding of the diversity of DNA binding within this protein family. Further unresolved questions remain in this field where SAS could contribute, such as the role of the two adjacent DNA-binding sites that are commonly found in operators regulated by MarR family proteins (64). An increased understanding of DNA binding and release mechanisms within the MarR family is essential to understand mechanisms for multiresistance and how these could be addressed therapeutically to improve worldwide health.
Gene regulatory networks and hierarchies in bacterial pathogens
2023, Molecular Medical Microbiology, Third EditionResistance mechanisms in Gram-negative bacteria
2022, Medicina IntensivaOhr – OhrR, a neglected and highly efficient antioxidant system: Structure, catalysis, phylogeny, regulation, and physiological roles
2022, Free Radical Biology and MedicineCitation Excerpt :Curiously, two (Pf101_5720 and Pf101_2263) out of the six ohr genes from P. fluorescens Pf0-1 are predicted to be part of an operon with putative alternative sigma factors (personal observation). Considering that the MarR family of transcription factors is restricted to Bacteria and Archaea [81,82], the regulation of ohr in eukaryotes remains to be investigated. The ability of OhrR to sense a specific oxidant (OHP) and mount the transcriptional response involves redox-dependent structural switches.
New Global Insights on the Regulation of the Biphasic Life Cycle and Virulence Via ClpP-Dependent Proteolysis in Legionella pneumophila
2022, Molecular and Cellular ProteomicsCitation Excerpt :In this study, we discovered that the abundance of key transcriptional regulators was controlled in a ClpP-dependent manner (supplemental Table S14). The downregulation of several RP-specific regulators in the TP of WT depended on ClpP, including Fis1, Fis2, and Fis3 (regulators that repress the expression of numerous effector-encoding genes) (80) and Lpg1212 (a MarR transcriptional regulatory protein) (81–84). Notably, several TP-specific proteins that were downregulated in the RP of the WT were upregulated in the ΔclpP strain, including Lpg0689 (a Dps-like DNA-binding stress protein previously found abundant in starved E. coli that can be DNase resistant when complexed with DNA) (85–87), Lpg1192 (a ThiJ/PfpI family transcriptional regulator) (88), DnaJ (a curved DNA-binding protein) (89–92), MraZ (a DNA-binding transcription factor; its overproduction in E. coli inhibited cell division) (93), LqsR (a novel pleiotropic regulator involved in regulating the bacterial growth phase switch, pathogen–host cell interactions, motility, natural competence, and filament production) (21, 94–96), and IHFA/IHFB (two integrating host factors that form a heterodimer and play an integral role in the global regulatory system governing the transition from the RP to TP) (26, 27).
Molecular Evolution of Transition Metal Bioavailability at the Host–Pathogen Interface
2021, Trends in MicrobiologyCitation Excerpt :Diversification of a metallosensor family may occur through gene duplication events that expand the evolutionary space of a protein without compromising an essential primordial function. In the case of MarR (multiple antibiotic resistance repressor), an ancestral family of transcriptional regulators that predates the divergence of Bacteria and Archaea, gene duplication events are thought to have been the primordial means by which this family diversified [107]. On the other hand, horizontal gene transfer in polymicrobial communities has likely played an important role in the evolution of the metal-sensing motifs in metallosensors [103].